Perhaps the most criticized call in baseball revolves around the strike strike zone. Heck, even I criticize the calls made by umpires calling balls and strikes when I'm watching professional games. I don't know if it's the frequency of the call (every 40 seconds or so) or if it's just something fun to complain about when our favorite pitchers are struggling - but at some point we've all yelled at an umpire about the strike zone.
What always gets me, though, is how many times I hear "Wow, pretty pitch!" when a pitch is about six inches off the plate (sometimes a full 12) and up at some kids' shoulders. I know parents think their kid is destined to win the Cy Young his rookie season at age 17, but come on - let's be real about what the strike zone is.
Throwing a Strike is Hard to Do
I always cringe when some coach or parent - or even some well-meaning outfielder chasing butterflies - yells to the pitcher to simply throw a strike. Do they have any idea how difficult it really is? Let's look at the simple geometry of the affair:
Home plate is only 17 inches across. The ball is a little less than three inches in diameter. The strike zone on an average teenager is roughly 33.5 inches tall. So, in reality, a pitcher is trying to hurl a three-inch sphere 60 feet, 6 inches to a space that's got an area just 17 inches across and 33.5 inches tall. And he's doing it while making the ball bend, twist, speed up or slow down in order to keep the batter from hitting the ball well.
My hat's off to anyone that can do that.
Every Umpire is Different
Those who've been around the game long enough know each umpire seems to call the strike zone a little differently. There are a variety of factors involved, but the biggest is the fact we're all different sizes and shapes (please, hold your jokes about what we do to scales when we step on them!). We simply see the strike zone differently.
But physiology isn't the only factor at play here. For some of us, there's a simple difference in understanding of what the zone is - we rarely take the time to look it up in the rules book, because we all know the long-lauded "armpits-to-knees, corner-to-corner" definition. But that's not really what the strike zone is.
The truth is, the definition of the strike zone (at least at the high school level) is somewhat ambiguous. Let's take a look to see what I mean:
NFHS 2-35-1: "The strike zone is that space over home plate, the top of which is halfway between the batter's shoulders and the waistline, and the bottom being the knees, when he assumes his natural batting stance. The height of the strike zone is determined by the batter's normal batting stance. If he crouches or leans over to make the shoulder line lower, the umpire determines height by what would be the batter's normal stance."
Let's start with the height of the zone. On the low end, there is no attempt to define what portion of the knee constitutes the bottom of the strike zone. The definition simply states "the bottom being the knees". Nor do we know which knee - front or back. Theoretically, by this definition, a pitch could cross the plate with the top of the ball (remember, it is 3 inches in diameter) just grazing the horizontal line of where the bottom of the front kneecap is at and then hit the dirt after passing the back ankle of the batter (think breaking pitch, like a curveball) and still be called a strike.
At the top of the zone we have a lot of fluctuation from player to player. Finding that space that's exactly halfway between the batter's shoulders and his waistline is really hard to distinguish. We all use some sort of device - we may use the bottom of the letters on the front of the uniform, or we may use the players hands when he's in his stance.
Even the width of the zone lends itself for some interpretation. Does the entire ball need to be over the plate, or can it be just a little bit of the ball? If we allow a corner of the ball to nick a corner of the plate, we've expanded the strike zone from 17 inches to 23 inches in width. Better for the pitchers, harder on hitters.
Stricter Definitions
The good news is most of us also umpire in leagues other than your local high school circuit. Those leagues may turn to the NCAA rule book, or even Major League Baseball's "Official Baseball Rulebook" (OBR). Let's see what help is afforded here:
NCAA 2-72: "The area over home plate from the bottom of the kneecaps to the midpoint between the top of the shoulders and the top of the uniform pants. The strike zone shall be determined from the batter’s stance as the batter is prepared to swing at a pitched ball."
OBR rule 2.00: "The STRIKE ZONE is that area over home plate the upper limit of which is a horizontal line at the midpoint between the top of the shoulders and the top of the uniform pants, and the lower level is a line at the hollow beneath the kneecap. The Strike Zone shall be determined from the batter’s stance as the batter is prepared to swing at a pitched ball."
With these helps, we're all looking for basically the same part of the knee and the same part of the torso. We're all looking at the same plate - it doesn't get bigger or smaller at any level. So we do actually try to maintain some semblance of uniformity between us.
In all leagues, by the way, it's customary to call a pitch a strike if any portion of the ball touches any portion of the area above home plate that is considered the strike zone. Those "borderline pitches" mean one little part of the ball touched one little part of the zone.
Nose to Toes, Dugout to Dugout
Now we know what the strike zone really is, let's be realistic. If amateur umpires called the defined strike zone all the time, we'd still be in the second inning of your son's little league opening game from three years ago. It's all most kids can do to get the ball within reach of a batter - heck, it's all most adults can do to get a "hittable" pitch to a batter. To actually throw strikes is, as we said earlier, hard to do.
So the umpires help out a bit. We "expand the zone", usually making it much wider. The only ones who really know how wide we open the zone are our umpiring partners, the catchers, the victimized hitters and the one or two parents that really are directly behind us in the stands. Even the pitchers don't know they're not really throwing strikes, though they've seemed to challenge Kerry Wood's single-game strikeouts record.
Why We Do It
We open the zone to promote hitting in the game, so we don't end up with a walk-a-thon. Those are long and boring games, and we don't want to be part of them. We like to see kids - particularly the younger ones - swinging the bat. So do the coaches, incidentally. We also do it to add confidence to your son tasked with the unimaginable chore of pitching. They're under a lot of pressure, and they sometimes need some help to boost their confidence and give them the will to keep going, keep trying. Who knows, someday they might be hitting a 17-inch strike zone with relative ease, and do it in front of 50,000 crazed stands while millions of others watch from an armchair or a bar stool.
So next time you start bellyaching about the strike zone, remember that the zone itself isn't as cut-and-dried as you may think. In fact, your notion of the zone may just be another Little League Myth.
No comments:
Post a Comment