This blog is dedicated to dispelling the innumerable myths I hear on youth league fields regarding the rules of the game of baseball. I use the rules set by the National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS), which are used most often by amateur youth organizations. If you have any rules questions, feel free to ask - your question may become a post!

Tuesday, June 28, 2011

A Fairly Fair Foul

The foul ball is one of the more frustrating things in all of baseball. Whether it's for the pitcher who finally threw that perfect pitch only to have it fouled off by his nemesis in the batter's box, or if it's the batter that finally got some good wood on a pitch only to see the line drive tail just outside the foul lines. Either way, every foul ball is frustrating.

But no foul ball is nearly as frustrating as the ones that aren't really foul.

But it hit the plate!

Working tournaments for youth leagues - especially those featuring kids that are younger than 10 years old - I constantly hear some mom in the stands yell about some high-hopping infield single her little Jimmy surrendered while pitching. "But it hit the plate," she bellows from about four rows up in the stands. "Even I know that's a foul ball!"

Is it?

NFHS Rule 2.16.1:
"A foul is a batted ball: (a) which settles on foul territory between home and first base or between home and third base; or (b) that bounds past first or third base on or over foul territory; or (c) that first falls on foul territory beyond first or third base; or (d) that, while on or over foul territory, touches the person of an umpire or a player or any object foreign to the natural ground; or (e) that touches the ground after inadvertently being declared foul by an umpire."

Nothing in there about bouncing off home plate. You might argue section (d) does, but that would not be a good argument. You see, the plate itself is entirely in fair territory. NFHS Rule 1.2.1:

"The infield and outfield, including the boundary marks from home plate to first and third and their extended foul lines, are fair ground."

Home plate is part of those boundary marks and, by definition, is in fair territory. When a batted ball hits the plate and continues into fair territory, where it is fielded by a defensive player, the ball is fair.

Screaming hit, screaming fans

Among the most daunting calls to make as an umpire, in my opinion, is that hard-hit bounder that seems to hop directly over the bag as it hugs the line on its way to the outfield fence. Is it fair? Is it foul? Of course, everyone in the park seems to have a better view of the play than the umpire does. Or so it seems....

According to the definition previously quoted, the ball is foul if it "bounds past first or third base on or over foul territory". Also remember that the bag - first or third base, respectively - is part of fair territory. If the ball hits fair territory before it reaches the bag and goes directly over the base as it passes it's a fair ball. Even if the next time it touches the ground is in foul territory, it's a fair ball.

Clear as a cloud of chalk?

To make things easier (on the umpires, at least), any ball that is called foul by the umpires is a foul ball. Period. There's no debate about it.

This is a rule change within the last decade, and to be quite blunt about it ... I like it. A lot. It stops any of those arguments involving a livid coach asking for a foul ball to be overturned from happening.

Once it's called a foul, it's a foul.

There is one exception, however....

Poor Babe Ruth

If you pay close attention to the wording of the inadvertent foul ball call rule, an inadvertently called foul ball cannot be a foul ball if it never touches the ground in the field of play.

That means if an umpire rules a ball foul as it's leaving the field of play (think home runs here), and it's clearly a fair ball, all is not lost. The umpires can get together and talk about it, and make the foul ball fair again.

Just remember the determining factor here, like the ball bouncing over the bag, is where the ball was when it left the field of play. Did it hook just inside that foul pole (if foul poles even exist on that field) or did it slice foul 299 feet from the plate, just short of the 300-foot-fence?

Back in the days of Babe Ruth the ruling was simple: if the ball landed in the seats in what would have been fair territory, it's a fair ball. But if it hooked around the pole to land in what would have been foul ground, it's a foul ball.

I wonder how many home runs that cost The Sultan of Swat back in the day.

My guess is he lost WAY more than you think your son or daughter has lost to those pesky amateur umpires you're just certain are in the hip pockets of someone in the opposing dugout....

Wednesday, June 22, 2011

A Balk is a Balk is a Balk is a....

One of the biggest misconceptions about the rules governing the pitcher in baseball is the balk rule is designed to prevent the pitcher from deceiving the batter, or any of the runners.

The truth is the entire game of baseball is about deception - thus curveballs, sliders, change-ups and cut fastballs. That's why there are signs and steals and hit-and-run plays. Deception is all over. So what, exactly, is the point of the balk rule?

Simply put, it is to prevent one team from gaining an unfair advantage over the other. With that in mind, there are more than 15 ways a pitcher can commit a balk. Some are obvious, others aren't. Knowing what, exactly, constitutes a balk can be a daunting task for umpires, coaches and fans in the stands alike.

When I first began umpiring I was told, "if it looks goofy, it's probably a balk." While the sentiment is well and good, it's better to know what a balk is and what it isn't.

From the Windup

While a pitcher is much less likely to commit a balk while in the windup position, a balk is not impossible. When in the windup, a pitcher's hands start together at the front of his body, at his sides or with one in front of his body and one at his side. His pivot foot (the foot he pushes off with) must be in contact with the pitching rubber; his non-pivot foot may be in any position on or behind a line extending through the front edge of the pitching rubber. While in this position, a pitcher has only two options: pitch to the batter or step off the rubber, becoming a fielder.

If the pitcher steps off the rubber, he effectively becomes a fielder. But he needs to step off the rubber legally - pivot foot first. Fielders cannot commit a balk, can they? If they make any motion that mimics a natural pitching motion while near the pitching rubber, yes.

NFHS rule 6-2-5:
"It is also a balk if a runner or runners are on base and the pitcher, while he is not touching the pitcher's plate, makes any movement naturally associated with his pitch, or he places his feet on or astride the pitcher's plate, or positions himself within approximately five feet of the pitcher's plate without having the ball."

So, once the pitcher steps off the rubber to become a fielder, if he then makes any motion that mimics his pitching motion, the correct ruling is a balk.

If the pitcher remains in contact with the rubber, however, then he needs to pitch to the batter. That motion must be a singular, continuous motion without interruption or alteration. This motion is typically determined after observing the pitcher in warm-ups - that's where the umpires get a feel for what is natural for that particular pitcher. Any hitch or extra pump in his delivery might be considered a balk.

But the key word there is "might".

From "The Stretch"

Here is where most pitchers get in trouble - and where most fans and coaches protest. Here are a few of the most obvious ways to commit a balk (remember a balk cannot be committed without runners on base):

Apply a foreign substance to the ball, like spit or petroleum jelly. Spitting on the ball or the glove. Rubbing the ball on the glove, clothing or person IF it defaces the ball. Discoloring the ball with dirt. Bringing the pitching hand in contact without distinctly wiping of the pitching hand before it touches the ball. Dropping the ball, and the ball does not cross a foul line. Feinting toward the batter. (See NFHS rule 6-2-1 sections a-e, rule 6-2-4a.)

There are some more complicated balks, however. Most of them involve making a distinction between a pick-off play and an actual pitch. For instance, "while he is touching the pitcher's plate ... any feinting toward the batter or first base". The faking to the batter is easy enough, but what about to first base?

In this situation, the common balk is when a right-handed pitcher executes a jump-turn to pick off a runner at first and then fakes the throw. The jump-turn is a tricky maneuver for an umpire to judge. Let's take a look at the rulebook.

In order to be able to legally feint a throw to first, he must "first step clearly backward off the pitcher's plate with his pivot foot first. After the pitcher has placed his pivot foot on the ground clearly behind the plate, he then has the right to throw or feint to a base the same as that of any other infielder." (NFHS rule 6.1.3)

The bottom line, the pitcher must move his back foot first, and have it planted on the ground before he removes his front foot from the ground. When the feet come off the ground together, he must throw to the base or he has committed a balk.

Another typically involves left-handed pitchers and their pickoff move to first base. It's all about the front foot (non-pivot foot). It cannot travel too far toward second or toward home if the pitcher is intending to throw to first base.

First, the step directly toward the base. There is no set-in-stone definition in the NFHS book telling what, exactly, constitutes a step directly to first base. As a general rule of thumb, though, the pitcher can step anywhere between the perpendicular plane of the front of the pitching rubber and an imaginary line from the third-base side of the pitching rubber and the start of the running lane on the first base foul line and still be able to throw to first base. Once his front foot has crossed that imaginary line drawn from the pitching rubber and the running line, the pitcher needs to complete his delivery to the plate.

This is a judgement call for the umpire. More often than not the umpire will rule in favor of the offense, but it is a judgement call nonetheless.

A portion of the pitcher's step that is not a judgement call is the part involving the front foot being lifted from the ground. A balk shall be called if the pitcher "fails to pitch to the batter when the entire non-pivot foot passes behind the perpendicular plane of the back edge of the pitcher's plate, except when feinting or throwing to second base in an attempt to put out a runner." (NFHS rule 6-2-4f)

The common mistake is thinking the pitcher must deliver to the plate once his front foot reaches his back leg. That is simply false. The rule states the foot must cross behind - all the way behind - the back edge of the pitching rubber. Once the pitcher's front foot has done that, he's committed to the pitch and cannot legally attempt a pickoff at first base.

But, if the runner breaks for second early enough, the pitcher can throw to second in an attempt to put him out. NFHS rule 6-2-4b states a balk shall be called for "failing to step with the non pivot foot directly toward a base (occupied or unoccupied) when throwing or feinting there in an attempt to put out, or drive back a runner; or throwing or feinting to any unoccupied base when it is not an attempt to put out or drive back a runner."

This brings up the final portion of the discussion - the throw to the unoccupied base. Remember that a base is not occupied until a runner has legally obtained it - that is, he's reached the base and not been put out. Also, a base is considered occupied until a runner has legally obtained the next base.

In a scenario where a runner from first base jumps just a little early and the pitcher executes a "spaghetti move" to second base, throwing ahead of the runner to put him out, the pitcher is well within his rights. That is, provided it is done in one complete, continuous motion. Remember he isn't allowed to throw to an unoccupied base unless it is "an attempt to put out or drive back a runner".

One Last Thing

The hardest thing about the balk rule is the way it is administered. According to NFHS rules (official high school rules), a balk is an immediate dead ball. If, for instance, the pitcher completes his delivery of the pitch after the balk is called and the batter hits a home run, well, it's all just for show. The home run doesn't count and the penalty for the balk is applied. The pitch didn't officially happen. The batter remains at bat and they continue the game.

NFHS rules are unique in this - they're the only set of rules that demands an immediate dead ball. Other rule books allow the offense to choose between the balk that's been called or the result of the play that may or may not ensue - a delayed dead ball situation.

The bottom line: know what a balk really is, and be careful what you wish for when you're in the stands asking the umpire to call one.

Monday, June 13, 2011

You don't have to slide, but....

"Break it up, break it up!"

I cringe nearly every time I hear this yelled on an amateur baseball field. It's a familiar scene.

There's a runner at first base, less than two outs. Little Johnny hits a ground ball to the second baseman, who's going to flip the ball to the shortstop. The middle infielders are excited - they get to try turning a double play like their Big League heroes.

Then comes big Jack, sliding hard into the poor shortstop, just like HIS Major League hero, preventing a throw to first base to complete the double play. I always think, when I see this, the kid has somehow been been coached by Ty Cobb. That's remarkable, really - the Georgia Peach has been dead since 1961.

Thing is, the take-out slide is illegal. There's no such thing, in amateur baseball, as "breaking up the double play". You can't do it. And, if you try, the correct call is an automatic double play - whether the fielder (who is trying to protect himself and running away from that hard-sliding runner) throws the ball or not.

Here's the rule:

NFHS 8.4.1(h):
"The batter-runner is out when any runner or retired runner interferes in a way which obviously hinders an obvious double play."

NFHS 8.4.2(f), 8.4.2(g):
"Any runner is out when he, as a runner or retired runner, fails to execute a legal slide, or does not attempt to avoid the fielder or the play on a force play at any base; or intentionally interferes with a throw or a thrown ball. ...If, in the judgment of the umpire, a runner including the batter-runner interferes in any way and prevents a double play anywhere, two shall be declared out (the runner who interfered and the other runner involved). If a retired runner interferes, and in the judgment of the umpire, another runner could have been put out, the umpire shall declare that runner out."

NFHS 2.32.1:
"A legal slide can be either feet first or head first. If a runner slides feet first, at least one leg and buttock shall be on the ground. If a runner slides, he must slide within reach of a base with either a hand or a foot. A runner may slide or run in a direction away from the fielder to avoid making contact or altering the play of a fielder."

NFHS 2.32.2:
"A slide is illegal if: (a) the runner uses a rolling, cross-body or pop-up slide into the fielder, or (b) the runner's raised leg is higher than the fielder's knee when the fielder is in a standing position, or (c) the runner goes beyond the base and then makes contact with or alters the play of the fielder, or (d) the runner slashes or kicks the fielder with either leg, or (e) the runner tries to injure the fielder, or (f) the runner, on a force play, does not slide on the ground and in a direct line between the two bases."

So, how do we apply it? That's more simple than the rule.

First of all, the runner does NOT have to slide. The term "force-play slide" doesn't mean the runner is forced to slide, it means he's opted to slide on a force play, meaning he's been forced to vacate the base behind him.

(NOTE: Some youth league tournaments may require the runners to slide at every base ... however, National Federation of High School baseball rules - used most commonly in 14U, 16U and 18U tournaments, do not require the slide)

Keeping the pants clean

Let's say Jack, running from first base, is afraid of getting his white pants all dirty, so he doesn't want to slide. That's fine - as long as he either (1) stops in his tracks, (2) runs in a direct line from first base to second base and stops at the bag or (3) veers off in the opposite direction of the defender making the play.

Note that, if Jack settles on options one or two he MIGHT end up with a baseball in his chest or helmet. He won't be called for interference, but some mischievous shortstop may decide he'll try and teach Jack a lesson by throwing the baseball at the runner, who may well be blocking the perfect lane for a throw. I don't advocate that by any means, but it happens. Hey, if coaches are out there teaching kids to slide-tackle middle infielders, there are coaches (and dads) teaching their middle-infield sons to throw a baseball at some poor kid's head. Sad, but it's the way things are.

Getting dirty

Jack decides he's going to slide, a perfectly safe option. But first he needs to learn how to do so properly.

Jack can only slide in a direct line between first base and second base, and his slide can only carry him to the bag. He can't slide beyond the bag, or he may be called for interference. He certainly can't slide at the fielder at all - he does that and the defense gets an automatic double play. He can opt to slide away from the play, and that's just fine.

But Jack's best bet is to slide directly into the bag. He's protected there. If the defender happens to move into Jack's running lane, well, that's the defender's fault. That lane belongs to Jack, end of story.

Little League myth busted

When you're at the ballpark this weekend, please don't yell out, "Break it up!" when a sure ground-ball double play is imminent.

The bottom line is little Jack can't "break up" a double play. At least, not until he begins drawing a paycheck for playing this beautiful game. Maybe, someday, he will. Until then, he needs to play by the rules - which are designed to protect the safety of each player on the field.