The foul ball is one of the more frustrating things in all of baseball. Whether it's for the pitcher who finally threw that perfect pitch only to have it fouled off by his nemesis in the batter's box, or if it's the batter that finally got some good wood on a pitch only to see the line drive tail just outside the foul lines. Either way, every foul ball is frustrating.
But no foul ball is nearly as frustrating as the ones that aren't really foul.
But it hit the plate!
Working tournaments for youth leagues - especially those featuring kids that are younger than 10 years old - I constantly hear some mom in the stands yell about some high-hopping infield single her little Jimmy surrendered while pitching. "But it hit the plate," she bellows from about four rows up in the stands. "Even I know that's a foul ball!"
Is it?
NFHS Rule 2.16.1:
"A foul is a batted ball: (a) which settles on foul territory between home and first base or between home and third base; or (b) that bounds past first or third base on or over foul territory; or (c) that first falls on foul territory beyond first or third base; or (d) that, while on or over foul territory, touches the person of an umpire or a player or any object foreign to the natural ground; or (e) that touches the ground after inadvertently being declared foul by an umpire."
Nothing in there about bouncing off home plate. You might argue section (d) does, but that would not be a good argument. You see, the plate itself is entirely in fair territory. NFHS Rule 1.2.1:
"The infield and outfield, including the boundary marks from home plate to first and third and their extended foul lines, are fair ground."
Home plate is part of those boundary marks and, by definition, is in fair territory. When a batted ball hits the plate and continues into fair territory, where it is fielded by a defensive player, the ball is fair.
Screaming hit, screaming fans
Among the most daunting calls to make as an umpire, in my opinion, is that hard-hit bounder that seems to hop directly over the bag as it hugs the line on its way to the outfield fence. Is it fair? Is it foul? Of course, everyone in the park seems to have a better view of the play than the umpire does. Or so it seems....
According to the definition previously quoted, the ball is foul if it "bounds past first or third base on or over foul territory". Also remember that the bag - first or third base, respectively - is part of fair territory. If the ball hits fair territory before it reaches the bag and goes directly over the base as it passes it's a fair ball. Even if the next time it touches the ground is in foul territory, it's a fair ball.
Clear as a cloud of chalk?
To make things easier (on the umpires, at least), any ball that is called foul by the umpires is a foul ball. Period. There's no debate about it.
This is a rule change within the last decade, and to be quite blunt about it ... I like it. A lot. It stops any of those arguments involving a livid coach asking for a foul ball to be overturned from happening.
Once it's called a foul, it's a foul.
There is one exception, however....
Poor Babe Ruth
If you pay close attention to the wording of the inadvertent foul ball call rule, an inadvertently called foul ball cannot be a foul ball if it never touches the ground in the field of play.
That means if an umpire rules a ball foul as it's leaving the field of play (think home runs here), and it's clearly a fair ball, all is not lost. The umpires can get together and talk about it, and make the foul ball fair again.
Just remember the determining factor here, like the ball bouncing over the bag, is where the ball was when it left the field of play. Did it hook just inside that foul pole (if foul poles even exist on that field) or did it slice foul 299 feet from the plate, just short of the 300-foot-fence?
Back in the days of Babe Ruth the ruling was simple: if the ball landed in the seats in what would have been fair territory, it's a fair ball. But if it hooked around the pole to land in what would have been foul ground, it's a foul ball.
I wonder how many home runs that cost The Sultan of Swat back in the day.
My guess is he lost WAY more than you think your son or daughter has lost to those pesky amateur umpires you're just certain are in the hip pockets of someone in the opposing dugout....
No comments:
Post a Comment